diff --git a/IRaCIS.Core.Application/MassTransit/Consumer/SubjectVisitQCAndCheckConsumer.cs b/IRaCIS.Core.Application/MassTransit/Consumer/SubjectVisitQCAndCheckConsumer.cs
index f22bef067..dffb221c9 100644
--- a/IRaCIS.Core.Application/MassTransit/Consumer/SubjectVisitQCAndCheckConsumer.cs
+++ b/IRaCIS.Core.Application/MassTransit/Consumer/SubjectVisitQCAndCheckConsumer.cs
@@ -439,7 +439,7 @@ public class PMRepliedCheckChallengeEventConsumer(
         var checkChallengeDialog = await _checkChallengeDialogRepository.Where(x => x.Id == context.Message.CheckChallengeDialogId).FirstNotNullAsync();
         var subjectVisitId = context.Message.SubjectVisitId;
 
-        var subjectVisit = await _subjectVisitRepository.Where(x => x.Id == subjectVisitId).Include(x => x.Subject).FirstNotNullAsync();
+        var subjectVisit = await _subjectVisitRepository.Where(x => x.Id == subjectVisitId).Include(x => x.NoneDicomStudyList).Include(x => x.StudyList).Include(x => x.Subject).FirstNotNullAsync();
 
         var trialUser = await _trialUseRepository.Where(x => x.TrialId == subjectVisit.TrialId).Include(x => x.User).Select(x => x.User).ToListAsync();
 
@@ -449,24 +449,12 @@ public class PMRepliedCheckChallengeEventConsumer(
 
         var trialInfo = await _trialRepository.FirstOrDefaultAsync(t => t.Id == subjectVisit.TrialId);
 
-        string json = checkChallengeDialog.ParamInfo;
+     
         List<string> modalities = new List<string>();
-        if (json.IsNotNullOrEmpty())
-        {
-            List<Dictionary<string, string>> studies = JsonConvert.DeserializeObject<List<Dictionary<string, string>>>(json);
-            foreach (var study in studies)
-            {
-                if (study.ContainsKey("Modality"))
-                {
-                    modalities.Add(study["Modality"]);
-                }
-            }
-        }
+        modalities =subjectVisit.NoneDicomStudyList.Select(t => t.Modality)
+ .Union(subjectVisit.StudyList.Select(k => k.ModalityForEdit)).ToList();
 
-        modalities = modalities.Distinct().ToList();
-
-
-         var dictionValue = await CommonEmailHelper.TranslationDictionary(new TranslationDictionaryDto()
+        var dictionValue = await CommonEmailHelper.TranslationDictionary(new TranslationDictionaryDto()
         {
 
             DictionaryRepository = _dictionaryRepository,